I love the Bilerico Project. It's one of my favorite blogs to read, if only because they go out of their way to provide different perspective on issues within the LGBT community. The reason I love reading these various opinions is because they often make me question my own opinion or belief, which leads to me either change my opinion or firm up my previously held belief. Sometimes though, the pieces I read on Bilerico just infuriate me, as was the case with a piece I read on the way to work this morning (which, oddly I can't find anymore... wonder what happened to it...).
The author's premise is that the spectacle caused by Miss California's ignorant comments and the subsequent media rush around her and equally ignorant Perez Hilton is absolutely useless to the marriage equality movement. Furthermore, Miss California should be essentially let off the hook for her comments because she'd just too stupid to know better. I have several big problems with this concept.
First, let's examine the non-gay layer of this cake. The author presumes that because the girl is a Beauty Contestant, she must obviously be ignorant. Because pretty girls can't be smart, and women that would dare subject themselves to the rigors of a Miss America contest are even lower on the intelligence scale. While one might have understandable and justifiable objections to the ideal of a female Beauty Pageant, assuming that all that enter that contest are ignorant is mildly sexist and highly elitist. Am I saying that you should accept those people with open arms? No, because I think it's reasonable to say that you would choose to not associate with them. But to instantaneously dismiss them and put them down for being "dumb, pretty girls" is just as asinine as saying you don't believe in Equality because it's "just the way you were raised."
Second, dismissing Miss California's comments because she's just not smart enough to understand what she's saying is antithetical to fighting for hearts and minds. Fred Phelp's isn't going to change, but if you let his message go unchallenged, you are in essence validating it. I would not suggest you treat an out-right Bigot the same as a lazy, casual hater (what I would qualify Miss California as), but in either case if you let that message stand on it's own, you are validating it in the eyes of the masses. For some unforeseen reason, there are people that will look up to her and take her thoughts and opinion as their own, particularly if someone doesn’t stand up and say that those thoughts are wrong. If we are going to give her a by pass, we may as well forget about talking about school bullying as those kids are obviously not smart enough to know the difference either, right?
Finally, I cannot accept that exposing the issue to the public and putting in front of people is a bad idea, even if it's in the form of one prima donna spitting at another. Sure, it's then reduced to mindless quips, however this debate on Marriage Equality has been reduced to that by mainstream media in ever instance anyway. Shooting down Perez for standing up for our rights in such a public manner, regardless of his words, only serves to fuel to fire of the anti-gay torch bearers. Apologizing for his behavior only equates to apologizing for our outrage and anger, and I will be last person you will ever see apologizing for being pissed that I STILL do not have equal rights in the country.
So no, I don't think we should "let her slide" or move on to a "more intelligent" debate. Here is today's battlefield, and I say we stand and fight.
Showing posts with label Miss America. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miss America. Show all posts
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Why We Can't "Let Her Slide"
Labels:
Anti-Gay,
Bilerco Project,
California,
Haters,
Miss America
Monday, April 20, 2009
"It's Just That I'm Incapable Of Thinking For Myself"
"It's just the way I was raised." It's a common phrase tossed around by the bigoted-opinion-holding masses who feel that it's OK to discriminate, whether it be against sexual orientation, race, or gender. The theory goes that they were raised to hate gays or Jews or women, so there's just nothing they can do about their opinions. They are stuck with them, and you have to forgive them for their stupidity and not challenged them on those evil beliefs.That's about as intelligent an argument as someone saying they were taught to hunt while young, so you have to accept that they enjoy killing people. That's just the way they were raised. They are helpless to challenge their own beliefs, a victim of their upbringing, and we must embrace them for it.
That phrase is on my top 5 list of Things To Clearly Identify An Idiot. If you mean to tell me that you are completely incapable of challenging things you learned as a child, then I have to write off your opinion on every subject. If you truly can't separate childhood lessons from reality, then you obviously still believe in Santa Claus and the Eater Bunny, and anyone that rationally believes and accepts a fat man breaking into their house once a year is a good thing can't be someone worth talking to.
What? Too harsh? No, I don't think so. That line of reasoning is often offered up by people to justify their irrational hate. It also means that they know their hate is wrong, which is why they are offering up their parents as having the ultimate responsibility for their ignorance. So not only do they believe that magical rabbits that shit eggs exist, but they also feel it's perfectly OK to throw their parents under the bus. Man, these people are sounding more and more awesome by the minute!
It's OK to hold a belief that matches your parents. But it's not OK to hold that belief because you simply haven't considered other possibilities. We are all affected, both positively and negatively, by our upbringing, but we are not always a product of it. We have the ability to examine what has brought us to where we are in life and change or perfect that course. Those of us that do will go on to make a difference in this world.
My family gave me a lot of my traits and characteristics. But I've tried to analyze why I hold the beliefs that I've held, and if I ever come back with something similar to "it's the way I was raised," I take some time to consider it further. The next time that belief is questioned, I won't have a ridiculously ignorant answer. I'll either have a defense of that position or a new position all together. But to sit back and be complacent in life to only hold on to things we were taught as children… that is just plain sad.
This message brought to you by the ignorant ramblings of a Miss America contestant. May you and Anita Bryant live a happy, co-existing quasi-lesbian life style together.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)